Seriously. I do.

As a born and raised New Yorker, I’m particularly keen on the soft kind that you can buy from a man with a sidewalk cart or — even better — for a small fortune at a Yankees game.

But I also love hard pretzels. Is that the right term for them? That’s what I call ‘em.

And do you know what I love nearly as much as I love pretzels?

Data.

So here’s some of that:

A SUBJECTIVELY OBJECTIVE PRETZEL RANKING

by Ari Brown

Rold Gold Tiny Twists

I have to give these pretzels some respect simply because of how ubiquitous they are. Say the word “pretzel” and the vast majority of people will think of these guys. With that said, as a pretzel connoisseur, I must admit that I think Tiny Twists are what give pretzels the reputation for being a boring snack for boring people. These should really only be eaten on a commercial flight, when the dinner options are a mini bag of these or a defrosted chicken alfredo. All of that to say, they get a 1.5.

Snyder’s Sourdough Nibblers

Snyder’s is one of the biggest names in pretzels — and they’re at their best here, with the Sourdough Nibblers. Even as a pretzel fiend myself, I can admit that the traditional pretzel shape can begin to feel tired at points. Enter: The Nibbler. These perfect bites are toasty without tasting stale, dense without ever becoming a jaw workout, and best enjoyed straight from the bag with a tall glass of ice water and a movie you’ve already seen a few times (so you don’t have to worry about hearing the dialouge over the sound of your crunching). These Hanover-born pretzels have earned a 4.5 from me.

Dot’s Homestyle Pretzels

These are the pretzel equivalent of the new kid who moved to your town the summer before 6th grade and immediately became the most popular kid in your class. You want to hate them because they’re messing with the status quo, but ultimately you can’t help but recognize that they are actually delicious and worth the hype (it seems my metaphor has ended here). The scrumptious taste of MSG is unmistakable. You will overeat these, regret it, and then do it again. My sincere congratulations to Dot on a respectable 3.

Snack Factory Pretzel Crisps

These guys blew my mind when they first came on the scene, and for good reason. They are an all around respectable snacking option, both because of the range of flavors offered and the versatility of the shape, which allows for all kinds of creative liberties to be taken. They’re light, salty, and crispy — which makes them a good choice for people who tend to favor crackers. But to me, that’s also their core downfall. I give them a 2.5.

Trader Joe’s Pretzel Sticks

The blueprint for a crowd pleasing snack, this pretzel has a little something for everyone. Pretzel purists will appreciate the classic hearty crunch and flakey bite, while skeptics will no doubt be won over by, as the Trader Joe’s copywriter so rightly wrote, “the delicate flavor of baked-in honey.” Though my personal enjoyment of these pretzels makes me want to give then a perfect 5/5 rating, I’m settling for a 4 simply because there will be snobs out there who decry that these are not, in fact, true pretzels. Though they’d be woefully mistaken.

Uncle Jerry’s Handmade Specials

You can literally taste the “handmade” in these pretzels — which is miraculous, considering how widely available they are. These are amazing in all of the versions offered — extra dark, regular, garlic — but especially in the low-salt version. But be warned: These are not for the faint-of-teeth, as the effort it takes to crunch these is above average. But so too is the flavor. An easy 4.

NYC Soft Pretzel

My everything. My reason for being. The ultimate pretzel. When these are right (warm, soft, fresh), nothing in the world compares. But their one flaw is their inconsistency. A bad one of these can ruin your day in an instant. And yet, the promise of a perfect one will keep you coming back forever. Some say these are too salty. But one of their many charms is how easy it is to de-salt them to your preferred level; so that’s the complaint of an amateur. Long live the New York City Street Pretzel. In it’s truest form, an otherworldly 5 out of 5.

Union Square Pretzel Co.

(Formerly Martin’s Pretzels)

Are you sick of my NYC pretzel snobbery yet? Well you’re about to be. I grew up eating these at the farmer’s market, and to this day, my grandpa always buys them for me when he stops by. These look and taste how pretzels should. The closest you can find to them in a grocery store is Uncle Jerry’s, but they don’t compare. There’s just something about these. 4.5.

Pretzel Goldfish

I love pretzels. And I love Goldfish. But these bore me to tears. It’s not that they’re bad. They’re just not that good. 1.5.

Now Rainbow Goldfish on the other hand…

Disagree with my rankings?

Want to thank me for my service?

Have a suggestion for a brand I maybe haven’t yet tried? (Yeah, right.)

Reach out! I’d love to talk snack.